| Name | Show | Year | Role | Character | Theater |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lara Hayhurst | Legally Blonde The Musical | 2014 | Margot | Benedum Center | |
| Lara Hayhurst | A Musical Christmas Carol | 2015 | Caroler, Party Guest, Poorhouse Guest, Spirit at Window | Byham Theater | |
| Lara Hayhurst | A Musical Christmas Carol | 2016 | Caroler, Party Guest, Poorhouse Guest, Spirit at Window | Byham Theater | |
| Lara Hayhurst | Xanadu | 2018 | Calliope | Cabaret at Theater Square | |
| Lara Hayhurst | A Musical Christmas Carol | 2018 | Caroler, Party Guest, Poorhouse Guest, Spirit at Window | Byham Theater | |
| Lara Hayhurst | A Musical Christmas Carol | 2019 | Charity Worker, Ghost of Christmas Past | Byham Theater | |
| Lara Hayhurst | The Wizard of Oz | 2021 | Animal Handler/Lead COVID Compliance Officer | Heinz Field | |
| Lara Hayhurst | A Broadway Musical Celebration | 2021 | Lead COVID Compliance Officer | Heinz Field | |
| Lara Hayhurst | A Musical Christmas Carol | 2022 | Missy Watkins, Peg, Caroler | Byham Theater | |
| Lara Hayhurst | Sister Act | 2022 | Sister Mary Martin-of-Tours, Ensemble, Understudy for Mother Superior | Benedum Center | |
| Lara Hayhurst | Who's Holiday! | 2023 | Cindy Lou Who | Greer Cabaret Theater | |
| Lara Hayhurst | The Sound of Music | 2023 | Nun, Ensemble, u/s Maria Rainer, Dance Captain | Benedum Center |