| Name | Show | Year | Role | Character | Theater |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| David Toole | The Student Prince | 2010 | Actor | Ensemble | Benedum Center |
| David Toole | The Toxic Avenger | 2016 | Actor | Understudy | Cabaret at Theater Square |
| David Toole | First Date | 2016 | Actor | Waiter, Gabe, Reggie, Casey's Father, Stoner Guy, Aaron Understudy | Cabaret at Theater Square |
| David Toole | Pump Boys & Dinettes | 2017 | Actor | Jim | Cabaret at Theater Square |
| David Toole | Xanadu | 2018 | Actor | Understudy | Cabaret at Theater Square |
| David Toole | Once | 2019 | Actor | Emcee | Benedum Center |
| David Toole | The Sound of Music | 2023 | Actor | Admiral von Schreiber, Ensemble | Benedum Center |
| David Toole | Natasha, Pierre & the Great Comet of 1812 | 2023 | Actor | Standby - Pierre/Dolokhov/Anatole | Benedum Center |
| David Toole | The Music Man | 2024 | Actor | Jacey Squires, Conductor | Benedum Center |