| Name | Show | Year | Role | Character | Theater |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Peter Matthew Smith | Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat | 2009 | Actor | Pharaoh, Levi | Benedum Center |
| Peter Matthew Smith | The Student Prince | 2010 | Actor | Captain Tarnitz | Benedum Center |
| Peter Matthew Smith | A Musical Christmas Carol | 2010 | Actor | Fred/Businessman | Byham Theater |
| Peter Matthew Smith | Kopit & Yeston's Phantom | 2013 | Actor | Jean-Claude | Benedum Center |
| Peter Matthew Smith | Seven Brides for Seven Brothers | 2013 | Actor | Mr. Perkins | Benedum Center |